make or buy decisions

Outsourcing is a hot topic in business right now. Outsourcing is when a company decides to purchase a product or service from another company rather than make the product or perform the service itself. Many companies outsource components or even their entire product to another manufacturer. When companies make the decision to outsource, there are a lot of considerations. In this post, we will look at the quantitative factors that should be considered when making outsourcing decisions. Don’t forget that there are many qualitative factors such as quality and customer experience that should also be considered as part of the final decision.

Make more money now! Try our JOB search.

The quantitative factors for make or buy and outsourcing decisions are very similar to the factors considered for keep or drop decisions. Here are some factors you should consider:

1. Compare the variable costs to the outsourced price

With make or buy decisions, we will once again use a contribution margin approach. Separate variable product costs from fixed product costs. How do the variable costs of producing the product compare to the cost of purchasing the product from another company. At first glance, it may appear that the cost of the outsourced product is higher because the variable costs of making the product are lower. However, all costs should be considered.

2. Can fixed costs be reduced if production is outsourced?

Typically, fixed costs are the determining factor in outsourcing decisions. When fixed costs are avoidable, typically the company can save money by outsourcing. However, when fixed costs cannot be avoided, the company is paying to have the product made at a higher cost than the variable costs, plus it is still incurring all of the fixed costs it would have had if the product was still being made in-house. Look to see which, if any fixed costs can be reduced or eliminated.

Once you have identified the costs that cannot be eliminated, those costs are irrelevant to your decision. Remember that relevant costs are costs that differ among the alternatives. Therefore, if a fixed cost will be paid whether or not the company outsources, it is irrelevant. When calculating the current cost to make the product, add any fixed costs that can be eliminated to the variable costs identified in step 1. This total is the controllable cost. Compare this cost to the outsource cost. If the controllable cost is lower than the outsource cost, the company should consider continuing to make the product. If the controllable cost is more than the outsource cost, it might be wise to outsource.

3. Are there alternative uses for freed capacity?

Similar to keep or drop decisions, companies should look for ways to use freed capacity. If the company decides to outsource a component, will that free up space and manpower to make more units of the primary product? Additional units means additional revenue or other ways to minimize costs. For example, maybe the company is paying for a lot of overtime because of space limitations. By outsourcing a component, that frees up space and labor, allowing the company to reduce overtime. Idle capacity means costs being paid without the potential for revenue generation. Companies should look to minimize capacity that is not in use.

Final Thoughts

If there are no alternative uses for the freed capacity and fixed costs cannot be reduced, it most likely does not make sense to outsource. Outsourcing should only be used if overall costs can be reduced and if there are no qualitative factors that outweigh the cost savings.

Share This:

Related pages

calculating contribution marginwhat is the present value of an ordinary annuitywac calculationreconciling cashwhat is the basic financial equation for businessesaccelerated depreciation method exampleemployee medicare tax rateapplied overhead ratetrade accounts receivable definitionoverhead absorption rate definitionbad debt write off journal entryfinding the present value of an annuityvariable costing definitiongross profit method formuladepreciation methods fixed assetsaccounting equation examplechecking account reconciliationperiodic inventory system lifoexamples of period costsincome statement versus balance sheettraditional income statement managerial accounting examplemanagerial accounting equationsover applied overheadexamples of discontinued operationsvariable cost of goods sold formulafixed overhead costvariable cost per unit calculatorgrocery store accountingtrial balance lists accounts in what orderabsorption costing versus variable costinghow do you prepare a trial balanceunits of output depreciation calculatorhow to calculate bond premium amortizationcontribution margin formulawhat is the lifo methodretained earnings statement exampleformula for asset turnover ratiostandard cost per unit formulahow to calculate ending merchandise inventorywhy closing stock not in trial balanceaccounting inventory systemsaccounting calculations and formulasdiscount bond calculatorfull costing vs variable costinglifo periodicfederal income tax expense adjusting entryhow to figure taxes on a paychecksocial security wage base limit 2014classified balance sheet formatdb depreciationformula of accumulated depreciationdefinition of closing entriesbeginning finished goods inventoryexample of prepaid expensestatement of cash flows practice problemsoverhead absorptionpresent value of a single sum calculatorperiodic or perpetual inventory systemabsorption costing examplesfinished goods inventory formulahow to set up allowance for doubtful accountshow to find the predetermined overhead ratewhat are closing entries and why are they necessarywages accrued journal entrypremium bonds accountjournal entry for billing customerscash sales journalperpetual inventory system exampledouble entry for depreciationbest financial accounting bookamortization accounting treatmentaccounts receivable on income statementhow to calculate contribution margin percentagehow to calculate gross pay from netaccounts receivable contra accountincome statement with cogs